THE EXCHANGE INDIANAPOLIS

THE EXCHANGE INDIANAPOLIS The Exchange is a retail environment where consumers can buy, sell, and trade all types of entertainment such as video games, music, and movies
(1)

Two locations available in the Indianapolis area. One located in the Broad Ripple Village and the other Castleton. Stop by for a Great Deal of Entertainment!

RSDExclusives VinylCollector RSDDrops RecordHaul CrateDigging ShopLocal IndieRecordStore SupportLocal RecordSt...
04/17/2026

RSDExclusives VinylCollector RSDDrops RecordHaul CrateDigging ShopLocal IndieRecordStore SupportLocal RecordStore VinylAddict CassetteCulture 7InchVinyl ColoredVinyl Audiophile PhysicalMedia VinylIGClub SpinTheBlackCircle NewMusicFriday RecordCollection

Gotta catch ‘em all... then bring ‘em to The Exchange! 🃏✨Whether you’re sitting on a rare Charizard, a power-packed Magi...
02/28/2026

Gotta catch ‘em all... then bring ‘em to The Exchange! 🃏✨

Whether you’re sitting on a rare Charizard, a power-packed Magic: The Gathering deck, or the latest One Piece heavy hitters, we want to see your collection. From vintage grails to modern staples, we are officially buying!

🎴 What We’re Buying:

TCGs: Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, and One Piece.

Format: We take both Sealed Product and Individual Singles.

Payouts: Choose between Cash or Store Credit (perfect for leveling up your current deck!).

📍 Visit Us at Either Indy Location:

The Exchange - Castleton
🏠 5909 East 82nd Street, Indianapolis, IN 46250

The Exchange - East Washington
🏠 10019 East Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229

Stop by today! We are ready to take a look at what you’ve got!

20% off all USED items Friday,Saturday, and Sunday!!! See you there!!
11/26/2025

20% off all USED items Friday,Saturday, and Sunday!!! See you there!!

It was a long week, but our new spot is now open!!!! Come see us at 5909 East 82nd St. Same strip as our old location, b...
10/18/2025

It was a long week, but our new spot is now open!!!! Come see us at 5909 East 82nd St. Same strip as our old location, but on the other end next to Dominos.

Exciting news!!! Next week we will be closed for a few days as we move down the strip to our BIGGER and BETTER location!...
10/09/2025

Exciting news!!! Next week we will be closed for a few days as we move down the strip to our BIGGER and BETTER location!!!! Our new location 5909 East 82nd Street will be right next to Dominos!!! We will see you there!

New Releases this May!
04/29/2025

New Releases this May!

See you % !!!
11/25/2024

See you % !!!

Black Friday!
11/24/2024

Black Friday!

11/24/2024

Check out our new website!
06/19/2024

Check out our new website!

Check out our new website!
06/18/2024

Check out our new website!

Address

5975 E 82nd Street (Castleton) 10019 East Washington St ( Indy East Side)
Indianapolis, IN
46250

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 9pm
Tuesday 10am - 9pm
Wednesday 10am - 9pm
Thursday 10am - 9pm
Friday 10am - 9pm
Saturday 10am - 9pm
Sunday 11am - 7pm

Telephone

(317) 845-1309

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when THE EXCHANGE INDIANAPOLIS posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share